Visions for the jewish homelandthen, now, tomorrow sheds light on the surprisingly diverse and shared visions for realizing israel as a democratic jewish state. Naomi plans to provide security for herself and ruth by arranging a levirate marriage with boaz. Author of the awardwinning 20 book my promised land ari shavit hebrew. Ruth is a book for all times, whether written in post. David hornik 23 december i havent read my promised land. The outstanding scholar and community leader gil troy presents an impressive range of thinkers, from yesterday to today, from left to right, illuminated by his extraordinary commentary, all of which affirm the enduring moral character of the zionist.
The triumph and tragedy of israel, the new new york times bestseller by israeli leftofcenter journalist ari shavit. Shavit was a senior correspondent at the leftofcenter israeli newspaper haaretz before he resigned when a pattern of sexual misconduct came to public attention. Why we read the book of ruth on shavuot my jewish learning. The entry of historians into the debate over ari shavits lydda chapter, in his bestselling book my promised land, constitutes progress.
Wisse points out that the jews believe in the ultimate power of god as being the king of kings. Making jewish humor made bob mankoffs, and who also was on our list of listmakersbut who declined to make a proper list herself, suggesting instead that readers should read books that make them capable of laughing at. Shavits book provides an indepth portrait of contemporary israeli society in a way that few recent books haveor have even attempted. Although he is a columnist for the leftleaning israeli daily haaretz, he transcends tribal politics. A jewish mother from warsaw rescues her little son from two bullying german soldiers. Dec 31, 2014 ari shavit owes readers a response to the contrary evidence presented by kramer and karsh, as well as to the devastating critique by harvard professor ruth wisse who wrote that the commitment to truth is a further casualty of this book, to that of alex safian at the committee for accuracy in middle east reporting in america camera. In mosaic, ruth wisse writes that a casualty of the book is. He is a passionate zionist and proud israeli whose patriotism cannot be challenged. The annual ruth and phil sokolof lecture in israel and jewish studies is the fruit of a generous donation by the sokolofjavitch family. Wisse earned an ma at columbia with an awardwinning thesis on abraham sutzkevers poem green aquarium before going on to a phd at mcgill with what became her first book on yiddish literature, the schlemiel as modern hero, published in 1971.
There are two important stories about my promised land, israeli journalist ari shavits memoir cum interviews cum meditation on israel. When i opened david horniks frontpage magazine article, ari shavit s doomed israel, i felt compelled to answer him, as he had not read shavit s new york times best seller, my promised land. In traditional settings, the book of ruth is read on the second day of shavuot. Mr shavit subtly builds his stories with a mix of individual portraits, historical detail and personal memoirhe is that rare person who can listen as intensely as he can think. This chapter has been utterly demolished by ruth wisse, alan gerson. Shavit was a senior correspondent at the leftofcenter israeli newspaper. Ive been waiting most of my adult life for an israeli to plumb the deepest mysteries of his countrys existence and share his discoveries, and ari shavit does so brilliantly. She bridges the worlds of yiddish and american culture, of literature and politics, and of israel and the lit. If this is the secret of the book, it is also the source of its principal weakness. Wisse is a unique figure in american jewish letters.
What books should jared kushner have read about the israeli. Sep 02, 2007 ruth wisse has written a book on a topic that excites a great deal of attention now, but she has written it from an unusual perspective. She instructs ruth to uncover boazs feet after he has gone to sleep and lie down. Ari shavitts addition to israel is losing its soul books. Jan 15, 2015 the prior three books are on joshua, i kings, and jeremiah. In his july 2014 mosaic essay, martin kramer dismantled ari shavits.
Ruth ware grew up in sussex, on the south coast of england. The triumph and tragedy of israel shavit s book is the winner of the natan book award. In eight definitive lectures, harvard professor ruth wisse explores the greatest novel of jewish nationalism, guiding you through the drama, the romance, the politics, and the moral imagination of daniel deronda. Wisse is a research professor at harvard and a distinguished senior fellow at the tikvah fund. A beautiful, mesmerizing, morally serious, and vexing book.
Martin kramer teaches middle eastern history and served as founding president at shalem college in jerusalem, and is the koret distinguished fellow at the washington institute for near east policy. Ruth is a type of the church, the gentile bride, and boaz as the kinsman redeemer is a type of christ. Benny morris and ari shavit among them her negative judgments. What books should jared kushner have read about the. In a camera article, alex safian characterizes shavits lydda account as very deceptive. Ari shavit s book is one that everyone from the american jewish center and moderate left who cares about israel loves to love, just as max blumenthals book goliath is the one they love to hate. The treatment of lydda by ari shavit and my respondent benny morris.
Shavit is one of israels most talented and erudite columnists. Another reason for the reading of ruth on shavuot is that its story takes place at harvest time, and shavuot also occurs at the time of the spring harvest. Among historical narratives in scripture it is unexcelled in its compactness, vividness, warmth, beauty and dramatic effectiveness an exquisitely wrought jewel of hebrew narrative art. Books about the israelipalestinian conflict that jared kushner should have considered reading include like dreamers and the iron cage. Ari shavits my promised land is without question one of the most important books about israel and zionism that i have ever read. The bestcase outcome for coronavirus, and the worst. Speakers in this series have included former ambassadors martin indyk and stuart eizenstat, renowned authors dan senor, daniel gordis, and ari shavit. I can partially understand that, because shavit s book is a paean to the israel that many of us pine for. His superb portrayal of history and life in israel has received extraordinary acclaim which even extended to the anti. From alienation to monarchy maggid studies in tanakh yael ziegler on. This is the book that has the capacity to reinvent and reshape the longoverdue conversation about how israels complex past ought to. Ari shavit owes readers a response to the contrary evidence presented by kramer and karsh, as well as to the devastating critique by harvard professor ruth wisse who wrote that the commitment to truth is a further casualty of this book, to that of alex safian at the committee for accuracy in middle east reporting in america camera.
Kirsten nielsens comments on the book of ruth paint a rich and subtle portrait of its characters, carefully tracing the many connections between this story and other biblical passages, such as the stories of judah and tamar. A rebuttal to ari shavits book my promised land dr. The book of ruth illustrates the difficulty of trying to use laws given in books such as deuteronomy as evidence of actual practice. Ruth wisse, how not to remember and how not to forget, 2008.
Two acclaimed new books about israel betray a disquieting lack of moral confidence in their subject and its story. The ruth and phil sokolof lecture the schwalb center. Jun 10, 2014 during an event at the sydney writers festival last month, israeli writer and author ari shavit told a packed auditorium that his country was an oasis in the middle east. The most comprehensive zionist collection ever published, the zionist ideas. The book of ruth is a hebrew short story, told with consummate skill. Jan 31, 2020 the books are sorted in the order their recommenders submitted them. As a scholar and a literary and social critic, ruth r. Gross law and justice and the holocaust in poland ruth r. Taking in everything from the kingdom of david to the oslo accords, ruth wisse offers a radical new way to think about the jewish relationship to power. His superb portrayal of history and life in israel has received extraordinary acclaim which even extended to the antiisraeli.
The answers provided by ruth wisse are very interesting and combined led me to give this book 5 stars. This is the book that has the capacity to reinvent and reshape the longoverdue conversation about how israels complex past ought to shape its stilluncertain future. Building on arthur hertzbergs classic, the zionist idea, gil troy explores the backstories, dreams, and legacies of. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Her book is not about the power that israel exercises over. Our focus has been on the middle east and on history but we have often strayed from that. Ari shavit s my promised land is without question one of the most important books about israel and zionism that i have ever read. The new york times, zionism and israel, 18962106, selected by ruth wisse and martin kramer as a mosaic best book in 2019. Jul 01, 2014 in his celebrated new book, ari shavit claims that zionism committed a massacre in july 1948. The dahmash mosque in lydda in july 1948, after its capture by israeli forces. As an israeli patriot, ari shavit may one day question himself whether there is not something remiss when the worst critics of israel hail his book as a longoverdue example of soul searching by an honest israeli with the courage to expose the evil at the core of the zionist enterprise. Wisse mendele mokher seforim, jewish critic benjamin d.
Print key passages from daniel deronda, and explore the themes of each episode with discussion questions. Two acclaimed new books about israel betray a disquieting lack of moral. The jewish community, and its areas of residence, outside erez israel. Jun 27, 2019 a special achievement award goes to ruth wisse, whose the modern jewish canon made allan nadlers list and no joke. He contends that shavit keeps from his readers key facts, and he disputes shavits account, event by event, detail by detail. They are scholarly, yet easy to read, and each is filled with thoughtprovoking and illuminating information, not only about the book the author is addressing, but the entire bible. Wisse is a research professor at harvard and a distinguished. She was the greatgreat grandmother of david, and the genealogy of ruth 4, is the chief reason for the book being written. Leora batnitzky ruth gavison moshe halbertal hillel halkin jon d.
Books to read have been chosen by a loose consensus and. Books about the israelipalestinian conflict that jared kushner should. Dec 18, 20 their tragic land two acclaimed new books about israel betray a disquieting lack of moral confidence in their subject and its story the covers of like dreamers by yossi klein halevi and my promised land by ari shavit. Ruth 3 good news translation gnt ruth finds a husband. Ari shavit confuses selfcriticism with selfdebasement. This chapter has been utterly demolished by ruth wisse, alan gerson, alex safian, seth frantzman and others who have documented that shavit s depiction of the lydda battle is a perverse distortion of historical facts. In mosaic, ruth wisse writes that a casualty of the book is journalisms commitment to truth. Apr 24, 2014 in mosaic, ruth wisse writes that a casualty of the book is journalisms commitment to truth. Jan 25, 2014 the ari shavit of this book often sees himself as the awareness, perhaps even the conscience, of israel as it could have been, as he would wish it to be. The blind spots in the conscience and awareness of shavit in the book are also the weakness of the israel.
A special achievement award goes to ruth wisse, whose the modern jewish canon made allan nadlers list and no joke. The zionist ideas is a mustread, a comprehensive zionist bible for the twentyfirst century. After graduating from manchester university she moved to paris, before settling in north london. Ruth wisse has written a book on a topic that excites a great deal of attention now, but she has written it from an unusual perspective. This volume is a powerful addition to this critically acclaimed old testament library series. The old testament library provides fresh and authoritative. On the reverse of the jacket are blurbs extolling his personalized view of israel by the. That meant that god is the ultimate ruler who will wreak vengeance on the enemies of the jews if that vengeance is deserved.
Wisse made major contributions to yiddish literature as both a scholar and an editor. Wisse, a professor of yiddish and comparative literature at harvard university and a longtime contributor to these pages, recounts an incident from the fall of 1939. Librarything is a cataloging and social networking site for booklovers. From alienation to monarchy maggid studies in tanakh.
Kessinger publishing is the place to find hundreds of thou. From the founders dilemmas and romantic yearnings for statehood to. On the other hand, there is a darkly pessimistic aspect to it, and a painful. This is a list of books read by a group in the greater stony brook area.
To support this lecture, please visit the support us tab. The covers of like dreamers by yossi klein halevi and my promised land by ari shavit. It is set in the time of the judges not the best ones, if we assign it to the period of gideon and samson and it attempts to define the rights of widows and aliens within a society fallen upon hard times. Since the book of ruth ends with the genealogy of david, whose forbearer ruth was, it has been suggested that it is read on shavuot because there is a legend that david died on shavuot. The new york times, zionism, and israel, 18962106, selected by ruth wisse and martin kramer as a mosaic best book in 2019. Of the writing of books critical of israel by american jews, invariably liberals.
640 195 772 250 1332 393 1185 173 775 757 1434 1488 1195 1268 973 1225 748 369 54 1276 245 1387 236 1134 1142 870 571 1354 573 1577 673 357 310 684 861 123 619 780 692 1297 1357 1133 438 701 988 96